Monday, 20 July 2009

Text Heavy- A Rant

When friends and family visit London, they are always shocked at my coldness to beggars on tramps on the street. Here is a tale that highlights why I am so cynical.

One summers eve Bianca and I were walking back to my flat from the station. This is now a routine part of party prep, stop home, make-up, heels, B tries on all my dresses and then we clatter out to which ever event we are heading. This particular evening a woman blocked our path as we were walking and chatting. She was short, squat in a tracksuit with cropped bleached hair and a jowlley jaw. Before we could say a word she burst into speech

'Oh hello girls, I wonder if you can help me, I've been up to about 5 women and they all looked at me as if I was about to steal from them. I'm not a beggar, I'm not a weirdo, I not on drugs, I had a fight with my bloke and I'm looking for £2.10 to get a bus home. I thought a woman would help me, we've got to stick together'.

This was delivered with a huffy, puffy, worldly tone with a much head shaking to emphasise her points- namely that as a fellow female we should adhere to a solidarity. Bianca and I sympathetically said that we had no change sorry, which I do believe was true at this time. She furiously condemned us for being a traitor to the female species and walked on her way.

It was perhaps a month later that I was sat with Christelle, maybe 10 minutes away from the station outside a bar. It was a Saturday afternoon and we were having a sneaky glass of wine in the rain. A woman was shuffling down the street and pulled up a metal chair at our table. I thought she looked familiar and it didn't take me long to realise why...

'Oh hello girls, I wonder if you can help me, I've been up to about 5 women and they all looked at me as if I was about to steal from them. I'm not a beggar, I'm not a weirdo, I not on drugs, I had a fight with my bloke and I'm looking for £2.10 to get a bus home. I thought a woman would help me, we've got to stick together'

EXACTLY THE SAME SPEECH. The copy paste tool has never been so easily used, everything, right from the 'I'm not a weirdo' to 'women sticking together'. I sat in disbelief listening to this parrot, and silently hoped that Christelle would not be taken in by the speel.

Luckily, Chris is also a cynic but this episode enraged me! Many beggars lie, I know that, and many also have their favourite one-liners, 'money for the donar kebab fund?', 'change for a ticket to Barbados?' these are regulars in my area but this woman...this woman was under the guise of a woman in need. She tried to steal from us by being disgusted at the lack of understanding between women, yet in doing so totally exploits the entire concept! To think I felt bad at Liverpool St leaving this woman in distress, to think that I felt I was letting down the sex. Her story uses a man exploiting a woman to pull the heart strings, when in fact she is exploiting many of us daily with her lies.

I caught the bus home tonight as it was tipping down with rain. Out of the window I watched pedestrians battling the downpour and saw a young girl being approached by the same woman. The girl's understanding face filled me with pity. I could see the woman shaking her head as she was probably receiting the very same speech again. I didn't see if she got her £2.10 for the bus.

7 comments:

Kate @ Très Lola said...

I just finished watching this:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00lfhhx/Famous_Rich_and_Homeless_Episode_1/

Don't know if you caught it? So it was unusual for me to stumble across your post in my rss just now... While she may have been spruiking the same story around town, i'm sure she had her reasons. It must be horrible to have to beg for money... it's all well and good for us to look on and tut to ourselves thinking women like her should get a job, but where would she even begin? Homelessness is a difficult thing.

jayne said...

I generally never give change to beggars. If they really need help I can donate elsewhere, a place that its more all encompassing for their needs and likely to go to said needs. plus the behavior of some beggars I've seen is awful.

-a woman in Dublin carrying around a baby for extra pity, but eyeing up clothes in the shops when she wasn't accosting us!
-homeless in DC (a city notorious for its homeless population sadly) holding signs that said "why lie, money for beer" which I found hilarious, but mildly infuriating
-and the best sign ever, a man in Cambridge, England carrying a sign that said "Help needed! I am being persecuted by the Socialist Party of Belgium"...seriously!?

Sarah-Rose said...

I tried to buy the Big Issue whenever I could but I only gave to beggars if I had the cash in my pocket.
But I too was taken in by a guy who spun a tale about his wife being taken to hospital & not having a car & just trying to get to her to see if she was okay. He was wearing a nice enough suit so I gave him cash. Then, 3 weeks later, I saw him giving another couple the exact same speech, in the exact same spot. Made me so angry.

catherine_sr. said...

I saw a woman on the subway in NYC, hauling a crying toddler with her, saying she'd just escaped from Hurricane Katrina and desperately needed money to feed her child. A man gave some money to her. A few minutes later I saw her shopping for video games. It made me so angry that she was exploiting this horrible tragedy that had just happened AND a little kid. I just don't give money to people on the street any more -- I donate to charities that I've researched first.
:: www.therenegadebean.com ::

Retro Chick said...

I think about this sometimes.

I'm pretty sure I've been stung by beggars like this in the past, and often for money I can't actually afford to give away.

I buy the Big Issue when I can and donate to charity, but I tend not to give directly to beggars, but if I am unsure wether a story is true or not then what to do?

Ho hum, it's a shame there are people that need to beg full stop. I would be angry if I found out someone had played on my desire to help a human being in need to steal money from me, but I wouldn't want to let that mean in future I didn't help someone who genuinely needed it.

everybodysaysdont said...

I've had this sort of thing happen to me a few times...including the one about the man being taken to hospital. It makes me really cross as well!! Grr! I used to give money to beggars sometimes, but I've really cut back now.

Pomegranate said...

It's not a bad think to snub street beggars- donating to homeless shelters is much better. You know the shelters are gonig to use the money to help them.

Independent Fashion Bloggers/

FEEDJIT Live Traffic Feed